working with survey files

Discussion in 'AutoCAD' started by Steve Wells, Aug 17, 2004.

  1. Steve Wells

    Steve Wells Guest

    We work from time to time with a couple of surveyors to generate subdivision
    plats. The local Borough review board is now requiring that a point list, a
    legal description, and closure information is provided when the plat is
    submitted. I am looking for a small, cheap or free program which can import
    an ascii file and will produce a legal description and point list. If
    possible, something which will provide closure information as well. I am not
    trying to practice surveying, just offer an additional service to my
    surveyor (who is not very computer literate). Does anyone have any
    suggestions.
    For drafting, we are running Autocadd 2002. We have Eagle Point at the
    office, but this is for a side business, and I cannot afford Eagle Point yet
    at home.
    TIA
    Steve
     
    Steve Wells, Aug 17, 2004
    #1
  2. Steve Wells

    Bob Morrison Guest

    In a previous post Steve Wells says...
    The surveyor should be able to provide this information from his/her
    calculations for point location and closure information. If you start
    generating this stuff then you are practicing surveying and are probably
    breaking the law. You can draw it, but you can't compute it.
     
    Bob Morrison, Aug 17, 2004
    #2
  3. Steve Wells

    Bob Morrison Guest

    In a previous post R.K. McSwain says...
    If it is a recorded plat, yes. At least in Washington State.
     
    Bob Morrison, Aug 18, 2004
    #3
  4. Steve Wells

    Steve Wells Guest

    I guess in the $100 to $200 range. By small, I mean I am looking for
    something along the lines of a lisp routine or something, or maybe an excell
    spreadsheet or something which will simply generate a table of the point
    coordinates, the bearing and distance between each set of shots, and the
    final closure. I am not looking for something to draw up the plat, or to do
    DTM work, etc. I'm not looking for anything "big" like Eagle Point or LDD,
    just a simple routine.
    I may have to quit being lazy (find the time between one full time job and a
    second part time) and try to write my own..... If I end up going that way,
    or if I find something along the way, I could re-post it here.
     
    Steve Wells, Aug 18, 2004
    #4
  5. Steve Wells

    Bob Morrison Guest

    In a previous post Steve Wells says...
    Steve:

    I guess I'm still at a loss as to why your surveyor can't provide this
    information. He had to have generated it when he computed the lot
    lines. He did compute the lot lines didn't he?
     
    Bob Morrison, Aug 18, 2004
    #5
  6. Steve Wells

    R.K. McSwain Guest

    Interesting. So if "Surveyor A" in Wash. State wants to open up shop, either

    1) He must do all the calcs/drafting work
    -or-
    2) He must hire a LS to do all the calcs/drafting work.
    But either way, an LS must do all the drafting work?

    In a large company, that would mean you would need a lot of LS's on
    staff. Seems kind of silly. But who am I to question the state of
    Washington?

    What sorts of methods are in place in WA to ensure that an LS calculates
    the location of every monument for every plat?

    Thanks.
     
    R.K. McSwain, Aug 19, 2004
    #6
  7. Steve Wells

    Bob Morrison Guest

    In a previous post R.K. McSwain says...
    That's not what I said. He must provide direct supervision of both
    calcs and drafting before affixing his seal to the drawing. A plat
    isn't "official" unless it's been approved by a surveyor. This approval
    is indicated by affixing his seal.

    So, a drafter and/or technician can work on a plat, it is just not
    "official" until the surveyor says so. To my understanding the OP
    wanted to file the plat with the local jurisdiction. The local
    jurisdiction requires legal descriptions and "metes and bounds". This
    work is typically done by surveyors.

    The one question that has remained unanswered is how did the lot lines
    get computed in the first place. Or did somebody just look at a drawing
    then lay down some lines and then say we better write a legal for each
    of these parcels. In most jurisdictions there are lot area requirements
    and minimum dimension standards. Typically, only licensed professionals
    are able to certify that the plat meets those requirements.

    That's why you hire surveyors in the first place. In Washington State
    to do any of the above is practicing surveying. To do so without a
    license is breaking the law. People get hauled before the state license
    board all the time for practicing surveying without a license.


    Bob Morrison
    R L Morrison Engineering Co
    Structural & Civil Engineering
    Poulsbo WA
     
    Bob Morrison, Aug 19, 2004
    #7
  8. Steve Wells

    Steve Wells Guest

    All of this work is being done under the direct supervision of the LS. I'm
    just trying to shortcut the effort of creating tables of info when he has
    provided me a standard comma delimited point file.
    We are only doing the drafting and layout work, the surveyor is the one who
    will actually file the plat. As to the requirement for the meets and bounds,
    this is for the boundary survey of the entire parcel, not for each
    individual lot. Because one portion of the parcel is bounded by water, this
    takes many survey shots. Because of the many shots, I wanted to automate the
    generation of the bearing and distances into a table. The surveyor has
    already reduced his raw data to a corrected data file. We have always done
    this long-hand with the surveyor. I just wanted to build a better
    mousetrap.....
    The surveyor performed a boundary survey with topo shots. With the surveyors
    assistance, a lot layout for the subdivision was generated. Yes, we the cadd
    operators did most of this layout, under the guidelines of the governing
    bodies. The layout is reviewed and approved (or modified) by the surveyor
    prior to comlpetion.
    I understand your concern for your profession, and that is why I am working
    with a surveyor, not advertising to perform this work myself.
     
    Steve Wells, Aug 19, 2004
    #8
  9. Steve Wells

    R.K. McSwain Guest

    Actually, that IS what you said. Let me repost your words

    </snip>

    To me, that means that only a LS can generate coordinates for a plat.
    Besides the fact that I asked a direct question as to whether an LS must
    make all calculations - and you said YES.

    I understand your final reply, but please understand that what you
    originally wrote gives the wrong impression.

    Many, many LS's sign and seal plats, metes and bounds, land title
    surveys, etc. without ever stepping foot outdoors.
     
    R.K. McSwain, Aug 20, 2004
    #9
  10. Steve Wells

    Bob Morrison Guest

    In a previous post R.K. McSwain says...
    Okay. I went back and re-read my posts and you are correct. I
    apologize for being a little too strident in my posts. However, I was
    under the impression that the surveyor of record did his computations
    and thus located all the points and developed the closure error.

    I am still a little confused about why the surveyor cannot supply that
    information. Certainly, the drafter can use the surveyor's information
    to draw the plan. The way some of the questions were posted led me to
    believe that the drafter was the one generating the points, not the
    surveyor.

    Again, I apologize for any misunderstanding.
     
    Bob Morrison, Aug 20, 2004
    #10
  11. Steve Wells

    Bob Morrison Guest

    In a previous post Steve Wells says...
    Steve:

    Thanks for your post. I now have a more clear understanding of what you
    are trying to do.

    Try this link for COGO software

    http://www.pcsurvey.com/pc_survey.htm

    The software looks like it will do what you need. There may be others
    on the market. Try a Google search for COGO.
     
    Bob Morrison, Aug 20, 2004
    #11
  12. In New York, only a surveyor can prepare a plat, and the surveyor must
    do the field survey. Why would any other entity take the risk of offering
    work that is possibly incorrect. I doubt surveyors would take the work of
    others without checking it. If it has to be checked, the surveyor might as
    well do the work, without the double charge for it to the client.
     
    Jack Goldstein, Aug 20, 2004
    #12
  13. Steve Wells

    R.K. McSwain Guest

    R.K. McSwain, Aug 21, 2004
    #13
  14. You could get the surveyor to give you his points file in text, and then
    imprt them with a shareware program called POINTOR
     
    James H. Williams PE, Aug 23, 2004
    #14
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.