Piping Models - Possible Sources for 3D parts

Discussion in 'SolidWorks' started by lmar, Sep 1, 2005.

  1. lmar

    lmar Guest

    Hello,

    A client is considering purchasing the SW Routing Module.
    They are a refrigeration company so they require the typical 6"-8"
    valves, pumps, check valves, etc... to build ice rink equipment.

    Part of the evaluation is to determine how much effort is required to
    create 3D models of various standard piping components.

    Basic flanges, Tees, elbows, reducers, etc... are represented in the SW
    library.

    Went through 3D content central and couldn't find any suppliers
    providing 3D models.

    Question: Which companies provide 3D components suitable for use as a
    routing library.

    I'm beginning to think that purchasing the routing program will be the
    easiest part of the process. Finding models suitable for the design
    library will be something else.

    Len
     
    lmar, Sep 1, 2005
    #1
  2. McMaster Carr, you just have to add your routing stuff.
     
    friendlyfreeriders, Sep 1, 2005
    #2
  3. lmar

    lmar Guest

    Thanks,

    Now if we could only get them in configurations with routing points and
    configuration properties filled out.....

    Len
     
    lmar, Sep 1, 2005
    #3
  4. Ya, that is the reason we would never pay for the routing module. For
    its cost, it should have all the fittings included for all different
    piping types and materials. How is it working for you? Everytime I
    hear piping (or routing) mentioned, I always hear the word crash.
     
    friendlyfreeriders, Sep 2, 2005
    #4
  5. lmar

    lmar Guest

    The number of standard library parts is weak - however, once you get
    use to using it the way it was designed (rather than the way I want it
    to work) it does a pretty decent job of it.
    Creating libraries is kind of lame (like who uses welded endcaps in any
    of their designs).

    The company I'm evaluating it for uses 2D to rough out the design. Most
    of the components are built in place "on the fly". Re-work, not to
    mention having fabricators design things on the fly was getting
    expensive.

    In 8 days I've been able to solidify the design for them and issue
    fabrication drawings.
    They want to go for fixed price quotes on the frame (skid) because the
    fabricators know what to quote on down to the number of welds.

    Most of the fabrication will be done off site - and then shipped for
    final assembly and integration. This is the second unit of this type -
    and the first to be designed using 3D.
    Should be interesting to compare manufacturing costs between the two
    when all is said and done.

    Question: Where does one find dimensions for weld o-lets and thread
    o-lets. I haven't been able to find any dimensions on any of the souces
    mentioned earlier in the thread. Several piping handbooks I've been
    able to reveiw don't contain the specification for them. Possible
    source?

    Len
     
    lmar, Sep 3, 2005
    #5
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.