New to SW

Our company is expecting to have to train a number of experienced Solid Edge
and UG users on Solid Works soon for an upcoming project. As of yet, one
person here has gone through some SW tutorials, but no one else has any
experience.

Our perception is that SW will be very easy to learn, especially for those
with the SE background.

The work we will be doing will involve modeling and drafting, including
large assemblies (10,000+ components, including fasteners, etc.).

Is there anyone here who's used both packages and can advise what things we
will need to watch for regarding performance or interface differences? (Or
anything else we should be aware of to ease the transition?)


TIA,
Tom Truman
ORT Engineering

 

I have never used SE, so can't address that part of. However, since I am
particularly keen on using hotkeys to enhance productivity, I would suggest
loading all of mine from the start. If you wish to go that route, I can send
you a zip file that has the registry entries and documentation that list all
that are standard in SW, and also all that we have standardized on here.
This includes what you would normally consider hotkeys (m-mate, n-note,
w-zoom to window, etc) and also the numeric keypad set of macros that give
you all the different std & isometric views at the touch of a key.

I would also suggest loading your SW application as C:\Program
Files\SolidWorks2005\ with the common files loading as C:\Program
Files\Common Files\Solidworks Data2005\. (Note - no space before the 2005.)
There is more than one reason for this suggestion, and I believe in it
enough to suggest that you uninstall and reinstall SW if you have not done
it this way. The first is that you will be able to use more of my help, as
in here's the file - load it. The second is that there will come the time
that you want to upgrade a machine to the next version and still maintain a
lesser version for customer compatibility, etc. and so you need to be able
to keep them separate. This is what I have learned from my experience. My
thoughts.

WT

 

Check this link out:
http://www.eng-tips.com/viewthread.cfm?qid=115577&page=1

 

Expect SW to be very slow on large assemblies, especially on drawings.

Jerry Steiger
Tripod Data Systems
"take the garbage out, dear"

 

....(clip)...

Tom, I STRONGLY recommend that UP FRONT you bring in at least one senior
guy (a contractor if necessary) who has a lot of experience both with
machine design AND with SolidWorks. The amount of time you will
certainly save WILL pay you back many times over. SolidWorks is fairly
straightforward to learn and use, but there are a number of ways that
you can paint yourself into a corner, just like with any 3D parametric
modeling software. There are also efficient ways to do things, and
bumbling inefficient ways to do things, and you will not necessarily
automatically find your way to the first group. In fact, without some
guidance you will find that your engineers and designers end up going
fifty dozen different ways in their design approches, and (take my word
for it) you WILL PAY DEARLY for that.

That being said, I recommend taking a look at the Web site of Matt
Lombard and his Rules of Thumb. That being said, the old link to his
site is no more, and the new link he sent me doesn't work. Email me
directly and I can probably give you a valid email address for him.
You'll find an email address on my Web site, or you can just unMUNGE the
address in the header.

Mark 'Sporky' Stapleton
Watermark Design, LLC
www.h2omarkdesign.com

 

As suggested by Sporky, you are jumping into a major undertaking if you
want to start with a project to handle a product with 10,000 pieces.

There are lots and lots of techniques to make large assemblies work
faster and better and you can search back in this newsgroup for some of
them.

1. How to use subassemblies to best effect
2. Using a dumb solid in place of a large subassembly in a larger
assembly.
3. To use or not use fasteners in some assemblies, and how to use and
organize those fasteners and whether or not to use ToolBox.
4. SolidWorks settings to improve performance with large assemblies
5. PDM

Buying the advice from someone who paid the price the hard way could
save you weeks or months of time as has been suggested.

Bo