Is solid edge comparable, better or worse than SW?

Discussion in 'SolidWorks' started by phil scott, Jun 28, 2008.

  1. phil scott

    phil scott Guest

    phil scott, Jul 4, 2008
    #41
  2. phil scott

    phil scott Guest

    I got the SE v20 disc and basics traiing package last evening...
    havent loaded SE yet.

    the basics traiining package is 5/16" thick, thick white 120# paper,
    30 or 40 pages. You draw a garage door side rail bearing and bracket
    assembly. big print, big simple illustrations... about 50% white
    space. The intro says it takes about an hour to get done.

    it will take me a bit longer Im sure. But its easily a tenth or
    less as complex as IV... and may be simpler than SW ... doing
    registration on the software looked complex though. .. thats next.
    then I will give it a road test to see of its as easy as it looks.

    there are 25 other tutorials on the CD apparently.. if they are as
    clean as this sample I will be real happy with it.

    **

    The equipment skid Im building looks really good to me, but all I see
    are the flaws.. my client and staff though run out to the shop every
    20 minutes to admire it... they want to know how come it looks so
    good. (I kept all the pipe on the same plane and its dead nuts level
    and perfectly parallel etc, creates a neat effect.. then I put the
    feed lines and controls in smaller pipe on a second plane.. next we
    will polish the copper and brass and clear coat it for photo's and
    close ups under bright light. its a hell of a piece. 8' x 6' x 5'
    tall. frame is grey painted 6" H beam and plate. I did them a new
    logo we will have lazer cut in stainless and gloood to the control
    panel.




    Phil scott
     
    phil scott, Jul 4, 2008
    #42
  3. phil scott

    phil scott Guest

    I was so happy with SE's basics manual Im gonna post a separate thread
    on progress... I have my current skid equipment project at a hold
    point for 10 days.... so i drove the motorhome to the coast (Moro bay
    and north) so i can study for 10 days in silence listening to the
    surf, Johnny Cash, Sai, Pink, Da Plattah's, an ....Lil Darlin.


    Phil scott
     
    phil scott, Jul 4, 2008
    #43
  4. phil scott

    Cliff Guest

    This is actually rather scary.
    The docs for CADDS IV took up about three 4 foot long shelves
    IIRC.
    The manuals for UG's API programming alone weighed
    almost 50 pounds and the user manuals were more IIRC.
     
    Cliff, Jul 4, 2008
    #44
  5. phil scott

    phil scott Guest


    Nah... just a lot of really nasty flat tracking accidents and some
    unfortunate encounters with government... it takes a toll.


    Phil scott
     
    phil scott, Jul 12, 2008
    #45
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.