Dimensioning to center mark rather than hole

Discussion in 'SolidWorks' started by Centerline, May 22, 2006.

  1. Centerline

    Centerline Guest

    Hello all,
    When I want to dimension a hole's distance from an edge in a
    drawing, it seems that I automatically pick the center mark rather than
    the hole edge when I click on it - resulting in a 90° mark every time.
    I have to zoom in on each hole and select the edge precisely to get
    its distance from the edge.

    I guess I could delete all the center marks, dimension all the
    holes and then add them, but is there a better way to dimension to the
    hole?
    Thanks
    Chris
     
    Centerline, May 22, 2006
    #1
  2. Hold your Shift key as you select the edge of the circle that you want.
    Keep holding it until after you click to place the dimension.

    WT

    Hello all,
    When I want to dimension a hole's distance from an edge in a
    drawing, it seems that I automatically pick the center mark rather than
    the hole edge when I click on it - resulting in a 90° mark every time.
    I have to zoom in on each hole and select the edge precisely to get
    its distance from the edge.

    I guess I could delete all the center marks, dimension all the
    holes and then add them, but is there a better way to dimension to the
    hole?
    Thanks
    Chris
     
    Wayne Tiffany, May 22, 2006
    #2
  3. Centerline

    Centerline Guest

    Oops - I should be more clear. I think you're describing how to
    dimension from the edge of a hole (i.e. the maximum or minimum distance
    from the hole edge)

    What I meant was I am trying to dimension the hole position, from the
    center of the hole, but when I click on the hole, I usually end up
    picking one of the line elements of the centermark. This results in an
    angular dimension from the centermark.
    Chris
     
    Centerline, May 22, 2006
    #3
  4. Centerline

    fcsuper Guest

    Or zoom in really close to the hole so you can distinquish its edge
    from the center mark, or put in center marks after dimensioning the
    part. :)
     
    fcsuper, May 22, 2006
    #4
  5. Centerline

    Zander Guest

    The 2 'axis' of the centermark work like an x and y axis. In other
    words, if you click on a horizontal model edge and then click on the
    horizontal component of the centermark you will get a linear dimension.
    However if you click on a horizontal model edge and then click on the
    vertical component on the centermark you will get an angular dimension
    (90 degrees).

    Zander
     
    Zander, May 23, 2006
    #5
  6. Centerline

    Centerline Guest

    Great stuff. Thanks, folks. I appreciate the informative responses as
    much as I appreciate finding out I'm not crazy and this happens to
    other people as well.
    Chris
     
    Centerline, May 23, 2006
    #6
  7. Chris,
    I've found centre-marks to be extremely unreliable.
    After making a few changes to model, even just moving hole a significant
    distance usually results in centre-mark dropping it's connection to the
    hole.
    Do your dimensioning to holes then add centre-marks later to those holes you
    feel are necessary

    Cheers

    --
    Neville Williams
    Z-Axis Design - NZ
    "remove the KNOT to reply"

    Hello all,
    When I want to dimension a hole's distance from an edge in a
    drawing, it seems that I automatically pick the center mark rather than
    the hole edge when I click on it - resulting in a 90° mark every time.
    I have to zoom in on each hole and select the edge precisely to get
    its distance from the edge.

    I guess I could delete all the center marks, dimension all the
    holes and then add them, but is there a better way to dimension to the
    hole?
    Thanks
    Chris
     
    Neville Williams, May 23, 2006
    #7
  8. Centerline

    Eddie Guest

    Chris,
    I whole-heartedly agree with Neville, dimensioning to center marks
    should be avoided. Center marks are draft/drawing items and create
    nothing but problems. We have several rules of thumb and overall
    methodologies that help avoid this:
    HTH,
    Eddie
     
    Eddie, May 23, 2006
    #8
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.