Dilemma on using assy layout sketch and wanting to use the parts in context in another assy.

Dilemma on using assy layout sketch and wanting to use the parts in
context in another assy.

I currently have a weldment with 18 parts. Each part is looking at an
assembly sketch. We decided to make smaller versions of the weldment,
so I looked into using the parts in a new assy. This would work, since
they are all looking at the assy sketch on the original assy. I then
decided to make all new parts in the second (smaller) assy, but did a
COPY of the original assy so I can keep the parts looking at the assy
sketch. I then deleted 4 of the parts to make a shorter version of the
weldment. All of the other parts are exactly the same as the parts
from the original weldment, but have different part numbers.

trying to solve this dilemma the past couple of days, and a early
option was to break all relations on the original weldment so I could
use the same parts in the new weldment assy. This would also delete my
"design intent", since its in the assy sketch.

What do most people do in my situation? Is it good/bad practice to use
like parts in multiple weldments? Im curious to see if some companies
do this.

Please post comments/suggestions.

 

I don't work with weldments, but I would have just made a new configuration
of the original assembly. That way you don't have 4 copies of your parts
with new part numbers. On the other hand, configurations may not fit with
other aspects of how you do business.

Jerry Steiger
Tripod Data Systems
"take the garbage out, dear"