At last, real rectangles in AutoCAD

Discussion in 'AutoCAD' started by Patrick EMIN, Aug 7, 2004.

  1. Patrick EMIN

    Patrick EMIN Guest

    You have been waiting for real rectangles in AutoCAD for years.

    The wait is over!

    Here is how it works:

    Draw a floating viewport in paper space.
    Copy/paste it in Model space.

    That's it!

    You've got a real rectangle, you can change its length and heigth and its
    center in the properties window, and you can change its size by grip
    editing:

    --
    /////
    (o)-(o)
    ---ooO---(_)---Ooo--------------------------
    Patrick EMIN http://www.CADxp.com
    The french CAD portal
     
    Patrick EMIN, Aug 7, 2004
    #1
  2. WOW! That is incredible. I can't believe that AutoCAD let's you do this,
    since the MVIEW command is not allowed in modelspace. It sure does work
    well though, even with clipped viewports. The only problem is that you
    can't rotate the "rectangle." You can rotate the clipping boundary.

    Very clever Patrick.

    Dan
     
    Daniel J. Altamura, R.A., Aug 7, 2004
    #2
  3. Patrick EMIN

    Patrick EMIN Guest


    And how do Autodesk "rectangles" list as in the property window? ;))
    Autodesk's rectangles don't have a length and height, wich is curious for
    rectangles, mine do.
    --
    /////
    (o)-(o)
    ---ooO---(_)---Ooo--------------------------
    Patrick EMIN http://www.CADxp.com
    The french CAD portal
     
    Patrick EMIN, Aug 8, 2004
    #3
  4. Try making a 1 unit box into a block, then insert at any X, Y scale
    factor... now you have a rectangle, that can be rotated and know the
    dimensions.
     
    Tracy W. Lincoln, Aug 9, 2004
    #4
  5. Patrick EMIN

    doug k Guest

    that is much more useful, and easily incorporated into a lisp routine called
    "rectangle".

    i'm too lazy to search (its monday after all), but i wouldn't be surprised
    to see one out there already somewhere.
     
    doug k, Aug 9, 2004
    #5
  6. Patrick EMIN

    Warren Trost Guest

    How are snaps handled in an unevenly scaled INSERT? Perp, nea, etc?
     
    Warren Trost, Aug 9, 2004
    #6
  7. Patrick EMIN

    OLD-CADaver Guest

    PERP doesn't work, but ENDpt and MIDpt work fine.
     
    OLD-CADaver, Aug 9, 2004
    #7
  8. Patrick EMIN

    OLD-CADaver Guest

    It is NOT a rectangle, it still lists as a viewport and can result in auditable erros when moving between different releases. It seems a dangerous toy to build into drawings that may pose a serious problem as a future legacy issue. I'd avoid using it, as it's benefits do not outweigh the potential problems.
     
    OLD-CADaver, Aug 9, 2004
    #8
  9. Patrick EMIN

    doug k Guest

    just fine, if you draw it with lines, not polylines (2005).
     
    doug k, Aug 9, 2004
    #9
  10. Patrick EMIN

    David Kozina Guest

    ....or "heavy" polylines, IIRC.


     
    David Kozina, Aug 9, 2004
    #10
  11. Not only can you not rotate it, but try copying it in model space....it
    doesn't work.


    "Dean Saadallah" <info from pendean> wrote in message
    LOL

    You cannot rotate to any angle, and it LISTs as a viewport: before anyone
    takes this to heart without thinking, beware of the obvious ramifications
    for the future.
     
    Casey Roberts, Aug 20, 2004
    #11
  12. Patrick EMIN

    Patrick EMIN Guest

    And a copy protected object! Whaooo! I could'nt imagine my finding had so
    many interesting ramifications...

    --
    /////
    (o)-(o)
    ---ooO---(_)---Ooo--------------------------
    Patrick EMIN http://www.CADxp.com
    The french CAD portal
     
    Patrick EMIN, Aug 23, 2004
    #12
  13. Patrick EMIN

    Xolo Guest

    Yeah, that's a neat idea, but it's still not grip editable (stretchable).
    You have to re-insert the block at changed x,y,z coordinates.

    Xolo
    Try making a 1 unit box into a block, then insert at any X, Y scale
    factor... now you have a rectangle, that can be rotated and know the
    dimensions.
     
    Xolo, Aug 26, 2004
    #13
  14. Patrick EMIN

    David Kozina Guest

    Huh?

    The Properties palette allow one to modify/see the block's x and y scales
    anytime.
    (One of the main points of Tracy's method.)
    (One can edit thus several blocks at a time, too, if necessary.)

    No, not grip editable - but not usually needed for this exercise.

    BTW, I also like to include a point (node) on layer Defpoints at the center
    of the block (the handle point). (So when it happens to be in an XREF, I
    can still snap to the node (since snapping to _ins won't work in this
    instance) :)

    Best regards,
    David Kozina
     
    David Kozina, Aug 26, 2004
    #14
  15. That is an interresting find. I am always more impressed with an old
    AutoCAD feature which I did not know over a new feature.

    Have any of you tried out the new AECPOLYGON command in ADT? I find it to
    be closer to what you may be looking for in a "rectangle", but still not
    quite perfect. You would still have to pick all four points to draw the
    rectangle, but when completed and then selected it uses some cool new grips.
    There are now grips on the midpoints of all segments making for an
    interresting new way to edit shapes. Also, the angles of adjacent segments
    are untouched, rather it will lengthen or shorten other segments because of
    an edit.

    Jeffrey K. Ries
     
    Jeffrey K. Ries, Sep 9, 2004
    #15
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.