2005 sp3 assembly weirdness

Discussion in 'SolidWorks' started by hayduke, May 11, 2005.

  1. hayduke

    hayduke Guest

    I just applied sp3 this AM, now I'm editing an assembly that's been
    around for a couple years, the base part is fully defined and can not
    move when I try to drag it, as are all but two parts to which I just
    deleted a couple of assy mates.

    When I drag the one of the free parts the entre assembly moves around,
    completely hosing the structure. If I try to drag any of the parts that
    just moved SW states that the item is Fully Defined and Can Not move.

    Sumptin's broke.
     
    hayduke, May 11, 2005
    #1
  2. hayduke

    matt Guest

    Hmm, yeah, that's strange.

    Do you have any Fixed parts? (not fully mated, but Fixed with the (f) in
    front of them in the tree?)

    If your base part isn't fixed, is it mated to assembly planes?

    The main possibility that comes to mind (that doesn't require something you
    wouldn't expect) is that some part other than the base part is fixed, and
    the base part is just mated to other parts which are allowed to move.

    I would also check subassemblies, flexible subassemblies and incontext.

    Actually, I would also go through and look at all the mates in the top
    level and subassemblies. SW has this way of not showing mate errors at the
    top level sometimes, and of mates getting lost or at least not shown where
    they should be shown.
     
    matt, May 11, 2005
    #2
  3. hayduke

    hayduke Guest

    Yes, the base parts is mated to the top level assy planes. Sadly this is a top
    level, top-level assy with (according to Assembly Statistics) 591 top level
    mates, 483 top level components, 374 bodies (mostly suppressed hardware).

    Time to put on my miners hat and start digging...

    BTW- I 'rolled back' to SP2 and it made no difference, seems liek I've seen
    assembly mates get messed up when saving them to newer versions, this was a
    2004 file last week, today is the first time I've tried to edit mates.

    Thanks
    Whit
     
    hayduke, May 11, 2005
    #3
  4. hayduke

    hayduke Guest

    Looks like something's messed up with one or more of the configs in this assy. It
    I go to the Complete Assy with everything unsuppressed (all the fasteners, etc)
    things work as they should, if I go to one with all the fasteners suppressed, it's
    crapo.

    I might look around for the 2004 version of this file to see if it was broken back
    then, but I've got work to do...

    Whit
     
    hayduke, May 11, 2005
    #4
  5. hayduke

    AC Guest

    Whit

    I've have seen issues here where a mate near the bottom to the tree
    causes components at he top to go under defined and float around. I
    assume something gets confused in the database as most times deleting
    and recreating the same mates or deleting the part then bringing it
    back in and using the same mates works ok.

    When this happens I usually suppress parts from the bottom up until I
    find the one causing the problem.


    AC

    To reply via email remove all numbers from address
     
    AC, May 12, 2005
    #5
  6. hayduke

    Art Woodbury Guest

    Sounds like the fasteners are involved in mating the parts, for example
    Part A concentric with Bolt 1 and Bolt 1 concentric with Part B. That
    would break the A to B relationship when the fasteners are suppressed.


    A trick I found a few years ago makes mate analysis a lot easier: Split
    the feature tree into 2 panes and activate the Properties tab for one of
    them. If you left click on a component, the Properties pane will show
    all the mates from that component to any other components. If you
    Control Left Click on another component, its mates are added to the
    list, and any mates *between* the two selected components are shown in
    boldface

    Art
     
    Art Woodbury, May 12, 2005
    #6
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.