2 things I didn't know 2 days ago Rhino to SolidWorks and 2007 Training

Discussion in 'SolidWorks' started by John Layne, Sep 30, 2006.

  1. John Layne

    John Layne Guest

    John Layne, Sep 30, 2006
    #1
  2. John Layne

    Muggs Guest

    There has been a Rhino plugin for SW for quite some time, but you needed to
    get it from the Rhino website.

    Muggs
     
    Muggs, Sep 30, 2006
    #2
  3. John Layne

    parel Guest

    Well- It was somewhat finnicky. It would import unknit surfaces in as
    separate parts that you would have to reassemble.
     
    parel, Sep 30, 2006
    #3
  4. John Layne

    Muggs Guest

    Funny, I never had that problem Thomas.
    I would create a Poly surface first and "mostly" it wasn't a problem.

    Muggs
     
    Muggs, Sep 30, 2006
    #4
  5. John Layne

    parel Guest

    Perhaps it was because they were on seperate layers. I havent used it
    in a while, but I am glad of the closer interoperability between the
    two programs.
     
    parel, Sep 30, 2006
    #5
  6. John Layne

    mbiasotti Guest

    Yes, the Rhino add-in has been available for version of SolidWorks
    prior to 2007 but it had not been updated since 2001 and there were
    some definite problems. With 2007, we updated it and built it in to the
    core product (you do have to check the add-in thou.) Additionally, you
    can edit a Rhino Surface from within SolidWorks (launches Rhino and
    opens up session with surface file.) You can also replace (re-import) a
    different Rhino file for the current one in the SolidWorks FM.

    Even with the current 2007 import, there are some current limitations,
    some that will be addressed in 2007 service packs and some that will be
    addressed for 2008 (next summer) along with possibly some new
    enhancements to further our integration with Rhino. I did say
    possiblyïŠ

    Currently in SP0 and SP1 you can only use the Edit Rhino feature if it
    is one surface feature. Also after working on the Rhino file in Rhino,
    you must save and close the Rhino session before returning to the
    SolidWorks session. We hope to overcome this in a 2007 SP. Also, if the
    Rhino File contains several non-manifold surface bodies, they will be
    opened up into SolidWorks as separate part files. We realize that in
    most cases, the user will want the option to open them up as one part
    file with several multi-bodies.

    We are committed to strengthening our partnership with McNeel and
    associates.

    If you have any further questions, I will try to answer them for you.
    We want to see Rhino/SolidWorks users successfully using these
    together.

    Regards

    Mark Biasotti
    Product Manager – Rhino Integration
     
    mbiasotti, Sep 30, 2006
    #6
  7. John Layne

    Muggs Guest

    Mark,

    Thank you for clearing that up. I've been using Rhino for quite a while and
    before SW surface capabilities were where they are presently, I used Rhino
    quite a bit more for all of my "Swoopy" surface creation.
    It's a rare occasion that I need to use Rhino because I "can't do that in
    SW", I mainly use it for creating surfaces using the MicroScribe (creating a
    grid of splines) and lofting a surface then save and import into SW.

    Now what would be nice (and you're not going to want to hear this) is a
    SaveAs .3dm, so I can go directly from SW to Rhino and then render in
    Flamingo.
    Sorry, but I didn't want to waste my chance at my request to "The Man"
    (appologies to John).

    Muggs


    Yes, the Rhino add-in has been available for version of SolidWorks
    prior to 2007 but it had not been updated since 2001 and there were
    some definite problems. With 2007, we updated it and built it in to the
    core product (you do have to check the add-in thou.) Additionally, you
    can edit a Rhino Surface from within SolidWorks (launches Rhino and
    opens up session with surface file.) You can also replace (re-import) a
    different Rhino file for the current one in the SolidWorks FM.

    Even with the current 2007 import, there are some current limitations,
    some that will be addressed in 2007 service packs and some that will be
    addressed for 2008 (next summer) along with possibly some new
    enhancements to further our integration with Rhino. I did say
    possibly?

    Currently in SP0 and SP1 you can only use the Edit Rhino feature if it
    is one surface feature. Also after working on the Rhino file in Rhino,
    you must save and close the Rhino session before returning to the
    SolidWorks session. We hope to overcome this in a 2007 SP. Also, if the
    Rhino File contains several non-manifold surface bodies, they will be
    opened up into SolidWorks as separate part files. We realize that in
    most cases, the user will want the option to open them up as one part
    file with several multi-bodies.

    We are committed to strengthening our partnership with McNeel and
    associates.

    If you have any further questions, I will try to answer them for you.
    We want to see Rhino/SolidWorks users successfully using these
    together.

    Regards

    Mark Biasotti
    Product Manager - Rhino Integration
     
    Muggs, Sep 30, 2006
    #7
  8. John Layne

    pip Guest

    We are committed to strengthening our
    This is pretty interesting. Can you describe what the user might expect to
    happen to dependancies if the Rhino object is edited (what sort of editing are
    we talking about, CV manipulations, trim manipulations, surface recreation,
    etc.) or replaced?
     
    pip, Sep 30, 2006
    #8
  9. John Layne

    mbiasotti Guest

    mbiasotti, Sep 30, 2006
    #9
  10. John Layne

    Muggs Guest

    Muggs, Oct 1, 2006
    #10
  11. I like and use Rhino as well and am happy to see the "upgrade" finally.

    What is interesting to me is that Rhino was developed by Ex-Autodesk people.
    And now a more integral part of SolidWorks!

    Welcome to the "Bright Side"...

    Aron
     
    Aron \(bacsdesign.com\), Oct 1, 2006
    #11
  12. John Layne

    mbiasotti Guest

    mbiasotti, Oct 3, 2006
    #12
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.